I would say it started in 1895 at the first international Zionist conference. It continued with WWI and the destruction of the Ottoman Empire (of which Palestine was a part). Then came Lord Balfours declaration to Rothschild promising Palestine to the Khazarian Mafia. WWII secured the creation of the squatter state.
Ahmad Ibsais it correct that this is not Netanyahoo's doing alone. Every Zionist Khazar and every Christian tourist that ever set foot in Palestine after 1948 is to blame for this genocide.
It’s never one man’s war: not Netanyahu’s, not Putin’s, not Hitler’s, not Tojo’s. It’s always a coalition that will form or expand or consolidate if its leadership orders troops to attack, and that coalition can reproduce behind new leadership to persist over decades or even centuries beyond the lifetimes of its original membership. In oppressor states (and very few can avoid oppressing at least some people enduring the ruling coalition’s misrule), that coalition makes war on some inhabitants, although “war” is a misnomer because it makes the conflict seem two-sided when it is one side murdering the other, even if those awaiting murder sometimes manage to mount a resistance that may even commit atrocities of its own. Those murders are indeed a genocide if their target is a set of humans as a collectivity to which others assign membership—as opposed to a voluntary association. That’s a lot of abstractions. Let me be plainer. Israel, not Netanyahu alone and not every Israeli, is killing people whose home is Palestine because it is the place of their ancestors’ birth, Israel has been killing them for a long time because the members of its ruling coalition want them to vacate their homeland, and that’s genocide.
100% right - and I would add that I researched, drafted, and submitted to Sen. Sanders and Sen. Heinrich a proposed bill prohibiting ethnic cleansing by any U.S. ally. Sanders did not even deign to respond in any way. Heinrich sent me a form letter that misrepresented my cover letter and did not even mention the substance of the bill.
Moreover, neither senator addressed my proposed strategic purpose of merely introducing the bill on the Senate floor: it would give Sanders and/or Heinrich a bona fide reason for demanding an official U.S. Congress delegation visit to Palestine to *rule out* the need for such legislation.
But neither ‘lawmaker’ would even discuss the proposed bill *or* the enormously powerful debate it would trigger on the floor of the Senate *or* the hugely impactful leverage it would give Congress to demand access to Gaza and the West Bank.
Why? Because the U.S. Congress is complicit in Israel’s longstanding apartheid regime, its methodical ethnic cleansing, and now genocidal campaign on the ground—and if a U.S. senator actually visited the country (and it is a country with an identifiable people, not a ‘territory’ or ‘region’), and then did nothing, the complicity of the U.S. government in aiding and abetting Israel’s crimes against humanity would be undeniable, and warrants would issue for Trump, et al. in the ICC.
It's prolly similar to some extent, but there are levels to shyt, and nearly 100 years of genocide definitely sets a precedent that Fauci doesn't live under. We don't need to have a comparison to an American shyt bag in order for this to be digestible, at least, we shouldn't need that. Israel is its own animal, but if we really need to draw a parallel to American actions, I'd say you're better off likening it to the genocide (yes, genocide) of Native Americans and Africans. In part because Israel based its colonization of Palestine off of those atrocities, and America is still perpetrating them.
You can "only live in the present time," but that is unrelated to this post. If the present leader of Israel is the only problem, then ousting him would change everything, but he is not the only problem, and the only way to change the problem in the present, and for the future, is to recognize and understand the history. Netanyahu is CONTINUING a genocide. That's the point Ahmad is making. A decades long genocide does not end with the eradication of the person currently leading the genocide, there will simply be another that replaces him. Nobody is asking you to live in another time, that is illogical. Israel's entire existence is built upon genocide, and Netanyahu has not been there since the beginning, he is merely carrying out what he was taught to carry out. Nobody is excusing Netanyahu with a post like this, Ahmad is elaborating on the actual issue, and you are willingly ignoring it to focus on a singular entity.
Perhaps, but Netanyahu brought the worst possible far right people into his cabinet, which looked cause so much killing and destruction in such a short period. So, he has to take on the responsibility of its wanting to stay out of prison in his orders on the killing, he is the PM, or now, and it is with his encouragement that this is all happening right now.
We know it started a very long time me ago, but it has never quite become as vile and evil as it is at the present time under Netanyahu.
Genocide is vile and evil at all times, it doesn't become moreso just because more eyes are on it, or the bombs have gotten bigger. Nobody is removing responsibility from Netanyahu, the point is, removing Netanyahu doesn't change the history, and only means that another will take his place to do the same thing. If we address Netanyahu separately from the core issue, then the cycle will merely repeat with another who will escalate it even further.
As per the politicians and so-called "elites", many of the supporters of Israel would not be defined as far right wing. Israel is propped up by the left and the right, and has been since its inception. Again, the point is, placing the focus on Netanyahu dismisses the history (whether intentionally or not) and creates the space for people to incorrectly believe that getting rid of Netanyahu solves the problem, which it will not do. Just like taking out Trumplestiltskin won't solve the issues in America that he has perpetuated and escalated, the problems will still exist, and may in fact become more deeply entrenched, as another takes over to uphold what has been in place since long before he was born.
I am well aware that removing Netanyahu would not solve the problem, what I said is that he, Netanyahu brought about the vast horrors that Palestiniabs are currently dying because of. The whole of Israel and its occupiers will have to go brfore there will be oeace for the people of Palestine.
The problem is where do you put them that they cannot start the same all over again elsewhere. They cannot ever be allowed to gather in one place, I have written this before, unless it is an island far, far from any civilisation with no means of getting off that island, plus all the other thinks not allowedso they can never escape. Which could mean they would kill each other off and end the problem for us.
The “Jewish” people have to stop “their”people! In my opinion, you can’t just claim “Jewish”, be anti war/genocide, and talk peace- you have to understand why “you” should leave/support leaving Palestine! How else then, can one be for peace, anti genocide/war, and still believe “you” should/can be THERE in the same breath/action?! “Being there” clearly equates the holocaust of (ODDLY); displacement, removal, erasure of; theft, misappropriation of EVERYTHING FALASTIN!
I have just said this in a comment I made earlier.
Not so eloquently or in such detail but fundamentally the same. To describe this horror as being the responsibility of a single individual is to divert attention from the very nature of the society that has driven this for generations.
Exactly this. I am so sick and tired of people not seeing israel for what it truly is and israelis for who they truly are. Murder and genocide is ingrained in israel's society and has been for decades. israel shouldn't exist. israel doesn't deserve to exist. israel cannot exist. What they are doing to Palestine is what they will also do to other countries if they are not forced to stop. zionism and israel need to not exist for this world to be a better place.
Jewish Mafia and Cartel running the world. Come on, how many countries STILL do business with Isra=Hell?
You have to stop separating zionism from judaism. It is a state that has been supported by Jews worldwide. And, now we have this massive evangelical cadre of zionists, well, that's the trick of Judaism, man.
Larry FInk? Schwarzman? Black Rock's and BLack Stone's cartel chiefs? Larry Ellison of Oracle? Karp of Palantier? Adelson? Ackman? ALtman? Brin?
You have to blame the synagogues and rabbis who have been teaching the young Jews that Israel is the vaunted land, their birthright, their LAND.
Are we that afraid of the ADL and IOF and Mossad?
These people are sick and pathetic. "Now Mothers of IOF Want Sons' Sperm for more Evil Offspring"
Realy well said: the so called west continues to hide behind games of pushing forward pantomime villains, while the colonisal occupation, dispossession and mass murder machine rolls on. It is this machine that must be stopped.
This is one of the most amazing short comprehension of the brutal zionistic failed project called Israel and rhe suffer of Palestinians. The project will last a bit, but not and never forever. Justice will hold them all (including their complicits) accountable for their crimes. There is a god that will - hopefully - judge them all.🙏✌️🇵🇸☮️
At 10:00am ET on July 4th, while most people were preparing for Fourth of July festivities, Shaun Maguire, a multi millionaire general partner at Sequoia Capital, the most esteemed venture capital firm in Silicon Valley, was rage tweeting about the “Death of the West.”
He posted on X; "[Zohran] Mamdani comes from a culture that lies about everything. It’s literally a virtue to lie if it advances his Islamist agenda. The West will learn this lesson the hard way."
Anti-Muslim hate is becoming extremely profitable in Silicon Valley as the tech industry pivots towards defense tech and embedding itself with the U.S. war machine. From funding Israeli defense startups to spreading racist conspiracy theories about Zohran Mamdani, VCs like Maguire are pushing a new brand of tech militarism.
Defense tech, AI surveillance, and far-right pro-Trump ideologies are merging in the tech world as Silicon Valley’s obsession with profit fuels a dangerous new era of "the war on terror 2.0."
I could not have said this better myself, a perfect response to "progressives" that want to act like this started in 2023
I would say it started in 1895 at the first international Zionist conference. It continued with WWI and the destruction of the Ottoman Empire (of which Palestine was a part). Then came Lord Balfours declaration to Rothschild promising Palestine to the Khazarian Mafia. WWII secured the creation of the squatter state.
Ahmad Ibsais it correct that this is not Netanyahoo's doing alone. Every Zionist Khazar and every Christian tourist that ever set foot in Palestine after 1948 is to blame for this genocide.
I disagree. It's not just Zionism, it's the colonial/imperialist mindset fueled by capitalism.
The thing is you that are refusing to look at who is the driving force behind this colonial, imperialist, capitalist force.
It's the Khazarian mafia.
That's why my husband's book, Unfolding the Arab-Israeli Conflict: 1894-1970, starts when it does.
Thank you for your confirmation. Your husband and I see some things the same way.
And AOC is as spineless as Bernie when it comes to Israel
It’s never one man’s war: not Netanyahu’s, not Putin’s, not Hitler’s, not Tojo’s. It’s always a coalition that will form or expand or consolidate if its leadership orders troops to attack, and that coalition can reproduce behind new leadership to persist over decades or even centuries beyond the lifetimes of its original membership. In oppressor states (and very few can avoid oppressing at least some people enduring the ruling coalition’s misrule), that coalition makes war on some inhabitants, although “war” is a misnomer because it makes the conflict seem two-sided when it is one side murdering the other, even if those awaiting murder sometimes manage to mount a resistance that may even commit atrocities of its own. Those murders are indeed a genocide if their target is a set of humans as a collectivity to which others assign membership—as opposed to a voluntary association. That’s a lot of abstractions. Let me be plainer. Israel, not Netanyahu alone and not every Israeli, is killing people whose home is Palestine because it is the place of their ancestors’ birth, Israel has been killing them for a long time because the members of its ruling coalition want them to vacate their homeland, and that’s genocide.
Yep. Domination. Listen to Turtle Island's elders: Don’t just repudiate….rescind the Doctrine of Christian Discovery!
https://paulokirk.substack.com/p/trump-and-company-anyone-believing
100% right - and I would add that I researched, drafted, and submitted to Sen. Sanders and Sen. Heinrich a proposed bill prohibiting ethnic cleansing by any U.S. ally. Sanders did not even deign to respond in any way. Heinrich sent me a form letter that misrepresented my cover letter and did not even mention the substance of the bill.
Moreover, neither senator addressed my proposed strategic purpose of merely introducing the bill on the Senate floor: it would give Sanders and/or Heinrich a bona fide reason for demanding an official U.S. Congress delegation visit to Palestine to *rule out* the need for such legislation.
But neither ‘lawmaker’ would even discuss the proposed bill *or* the enormously powerful debate it would trigger on the floor of the Senate *or* the hugely impactful leverage it would give Congress to demand access to Gaza and the West Bank.
Why? Because the U.S. Congress is complicit in Israel’s longstanding apartheid regime, its methodical ethnic cleansing, and now genocidal campaign on the ground—and if a U.S. senator actually visited the country (and it is a country with an identifiable people, not a ‘territory’ or ‘region’), and then did nothing, the complicity of the U.S. government in aiding and abetting Israel’s crimes against humanity would be undeniable, and warrants would issue for Trump, et al. in the ICC.
Beautifully and clearly explained argument which I agree with 100%. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
It's prolly similar to some extent, but there are levels to shyt, and nearly 100 years of genocide definitely sets a precedent that Fauci doesn't live under. We don't need to have a comparison to an American shyt bag in order for this to be digestible, at least, we shouldn't need that. Israel is its own animal, but if we really need to draw a parallel to American actions, I'd say you're better off likening it to the genocide (yes, genocide) of Native Americans and Africans. In part because Israel based its colonization of Palestine off of those atrocities, and America is still perpetrating them.
I can only live in the present time. Netanyahu is committing a genocide. He keeps killing so he avoids
jail.
You can "only live in the present time," but that is unrelated to this post. If the present leader of Israel is the only problem, then ousting him would change everything, but he is not the only problem, and the only way to change the problem in the present, and for the future, is to recognize and understand the history. Netanyahu is CONTINUING a genocide. That's the point Ahmad is making. A decades long genocide does not end with the eradication of the person currently leading the genocide, there will simply be another that replaces him. Nobody is asking you to live in another time, that is illogical. Israel's entire existence is built upon genocide, and Netanyahu has not been there since the beginning, he is merely carrying out what he was taught to carry out. Nobody is excusing Netanyahu with a post like this, Ahmad is elaborating on the actual issue, and you are willingly ignoring it to focus on a singular entity.
Perhaps, but Netanyahu brought the worst possible far right people into his cabinet, which looked cause so much killing and destruction in such a short period. So, he has to take on the responsibility of its wanting to stay out of prison in his orders on the killing, he is the PM, or now, and it is with his encouragement that this is all happening right now.
We know it started a very long time me ago, but it has never quite become as vile and evil as it is at the present time under Netanyahu.
Genocide is vile and evil at all times, it doesn't become moreso just because more eyes are on it, or the bombs have gotten bigger. Nobody is removing responsibility from Netanyahu, the point is, removing Netanyahu doesn't change the history, and only means that another will take his place to do the same thing. If we address Netanyahu separately from the core issue, then the cycle will merely repeat with another who will escalate it even further.
As per the politicians and so-called "elites", many of the supporters of Israel would not be defined as far right wing. Israel is propped up by the left and the right, and has been since its inception. Again, the point is, placing the focus on Netanyahu dismisses the history (whether intentionally or not) and creates the space for people to incorrectly believe that getting rid of Netanyahu solves the problem, which it will not do. Just like taking out Trumplestiltskin won't solve the issues in America that he has perpetuated and escalated, the problems will still exist, and may in fact become more deeply entrenched, as another takes over to uphold what has been in place since long before he was born.
I am well aware that removing Netanyahu would not solve the problem, what I said is that he, Netanyahu brought about the vast horrors that Palestiniabs are currently dying because of. The whole of Israel and its occupiers will have to go brfore there will be oeace for the people of Palestine.
The problem is where do you put them that they cannot start the same all over again elsewhere. They cannot ever be allowed to gather in one place, I have written this before, unless it is an island far, far from any civilisation with no means of getting off that island, plus all the other thinks not allowedso they can never escape. Which could mean they would kill each other off and end the problem for us.
It's like blaming Fauci for the covid vaxx injuries the past five years.
The “Jewish” people have to stop “their”people! In my opinion, you can’t just claim “Jewish”, be anti war/genocide, and talk peace- you have to understand why “you” should leave/support leaving Palestine! How else then, can one be for peace, anti genocide/war, and still believe “you” should/can be THERE in the same breath/action?! “Being there” clearly equates the holocaust of (ODDLY); displacement, removal, erasure of; theft, misappropriation of EVERYTHING FALASTIN!
A superb article,Ahmad.
I have just said this in a comment I made earlier.
Not so eloquently or in such detail but fundamentally the same. To describe this horror as being the responsibility of a single individual is to divert attention from the very nature of the society that has driven this for generations.
Exactly this. I am so sick and tired of people not seeing israel for what it truly is and israelis for who they truly are. Murder and genocide is ingrained in israel's society and has been for decades. israel shouldn't exist. israel doesn't deserve to exist. israel cannot exist. What they are doing to Palestine is what they will also do to other countries if they are not forced to stop. zionism and israel need to not exist for this world to be a better place.
Jewish Mafia and Cartel running the world. Come on, how many countries STILL do business with Isra=Hell?
You have to stop separating zionism from judaism. It is a state that has been supported by Jews worldwide. And, now we have this massive evangelical cadre of zionists, well, that's the trick of Judaism, man.
Larry FInk? Schwarzman? Black Rock's and BLack Stone's cartel chiefs? Larry Ellison of Oracle? Karp of Palantier? Adelson? Ackman? ALtman? Brin?
You have to blame the synagogues and rabbis who have been teaching the young Jews that Israel is the vaunted land, their birthright, their LAND.
Are we that afraid of the ADL and IOF and Mossad?
These people are sick and pathetic. "Now Mothers of IOF Want Sons' Sperm for more Evil Offspring"
https://paulokirk.substack.com/p/now-mothers-of-iof-want-sons-sperm
Realy well said: the so called west continues to hide behind games of pushing forward pantomime villains, while the colonisal occupation, dispossession and mass murder machine rolls on. It is this machine that must be stopped.
This is a Truth , which the Australian government , as just one example, refuses to acknowledge . To their eternal shame.
This is one of the most amazing short comprehension of the brutal zionistic failed project called Israel and rhe suffer of Palestinians. The project will last a bit, but not and never forever. Justice will hold them all (including their complicits) accountable for their crimes. There is a god that will - hopefully - judge them all.🙏✌️🇵🇸☮️
It's the fucking Silicon Wadi and Silicon Valley's WAR.
https://youtu.be/vKSKawpFsfs?si=atBNVvDJw17IPACz
At 10:00am ET on July 4th, while most people were preparing for Fourth of July festivities, Shaun Maguire, a multi millionaire general partner at Sequoia Capital, the most esteemed venture capital firm in Silicon Valley, was rage tweeting about the “Death of the West.”
He posted on X; "[Zohran] Mamdani comes from a culture that lies about everything. It’s literally a virtue to lie if it advances his Islamist agenda. The West will learn this lesson the hard way."
Anti-Muslim hate is becoming extremely profitable in Silicon Valley as the tech industry pivots towards defense tech and embedding itself with the U.S. war machine. From funding Israeli defense startups to spreading racist conspiracy theories about Zohran Mamdani, VCs like Maguire are pushing a new brand of tech militarism.
Defense tech, AI surveillance, and far-right pro-Trump ideologies are merging in the tech world as Silicon Valley’s obsession with profit fuels a dangerous new era of "the war on terror 2.0."